12.26.2020
Classics Challenge 2020 Wrap-up
Classics Challenge: Mansfield Park
My 2020 Reading life comes to an end
Classics Challenge: Mrs. Mike
I found Mrs. Mike in my books while I was sorting for the move. I'm know it came from my mom was she passed a bunch of books on to me but I can't remember if I had read it before. I think I had because I knew it was about young girl marries a mountie and has to learn to adapt to a much harder life than she's accustomed to.. But I decided to read it again.
(Side note: After reading this, I did finally give in an watch When Calls the Heart after ignoring Netflix's suggestions for months. Apparently winter in quarantine made me long for Canadian and Alaska themed stories?)
That was back in March. Today in December - I remember its about a young girl who marries a mountie and has to learn to adapt to a much harder life than she's accustomed to. That's it, that's all I've got. I did like it because I gave it 4 stars on Goodreads and even more importantly, lent it to a friend because I thought she would like it. So apparently I think its worth reading but not worth remembering? Or maybe its been a rough mental year. Probably that.
Okay, with further time I do remember thinking that I wish it had handled her interactions with the local people with the same skill as Catherine Marshall did in Christy. I can't think of any examples to back that up because - memories. I guess I didn't really think Mrs. Mike was awful or I wouldn't have recommended it to others but I know Marshall did such a wonderful job balancing the truthfulness of someone's feelings coming into a new experience with her desire to know and love and care for people and get to know them and the Freedman's lacked that skill. Christy is probably in my top 10 books list thought so that might be too high of expectations and I don't discount books because of issues like this because the author's viewpoint is as much a part of the story when reading historical fiction written in the past...but I can still wish it was done better!
Mrs. Mike is my Back to the Classics "Classic with a Person's Name in the Title" pick for the 2020 challenge.
12.24.2020
2020 School Year in Review (Year 2/Year 5)
What do you know about the Monroe Doctrine?
It was a document that said no European
country could interfere with America and that America could no interfere with
Europe. It was made by President Monroe and he made it because England was
capturing Americans and forcing them to join their navy against their will.
Tell what you know about Lewis and Clark.
Napoleon needed money and at that time France had all the land west of the Mississippi and so, he’s like “well, if you give me this much money, which wasn’t a lot, then I’ll give you this land” and President Jefferson said sure, we’ll do that and he gave him the money and then Jefferson sent for Lewis and Clark to be the captains of the expedition to explore the new land. And Lewis and Clark set out with a lot of men and they started at the Missouri and it was very difficult and there were a lot of Indians and they traded and some were friendly and some weren’t and there were a lot of grizzly bears and Lewis (or Clark, I can’t remember which) was almost killed by one. he was in the woods hunting when I big grizzly bear came and he couldn’t get up a tree so he threw down his gun and jumped into a river and yelled and the bear look at him in astonishment and just ran away. And then one time they came to a fork int eh Missouri river and the crew thought it was on way and the captains thought it was the to her way so Lewis went with part of the expedition to the south to see if that was the right way. And it was and there was a big waterfall and they kept going. At one point they couldn’t take the big boat they had to take everything in the small canoes. And at they meant an Indian tribe and there was an Indian woman who came with them named Sacagawea and she had a little baby boy and then they reached the Pacific. And when they went back to Missouri, only one single man in the entire party had died.
Would you like to live in Sparta? Why or
why not?
Not. Ever. Ever. Ever. I’d rather live in
a desert island by myself than in Sparta. Because people all walk around naked.
And people have to steal their own food but they get punished if they get
caught stealing their own food. And everyone shares meals, they come together
and shares a meal of a disgusting soup. Also, if someone wants to come into the
group to eat together, they have to be voted on, and if they don’t like the
person they squeeze their bread real hard before they throw it into the basket
but if they do like the person they put it in nice and light and fluffy and if
even one person crumples their bread, the person can not be entered. Lycergus
was the leader and he said he wanted a republic and wanted everyone to have
free choices but they couldn’t ask questions or suggest things, they could only
say Yes or No to laws so it didn’t quite work out.
Describe a picture from this term’s
picture study.
Our artist was Turner. There is one where it’s in the middle of the ocean and it’s all stormy. And they said he insisted on being tied to a mast in the middle of the storm so he could get a better view of everything. And he survived. In the picture, there is a boat being tossed and turned and there is a city behind it.
Samples from Jonah's Exams:
Tell about the Siege of Calais or Wat Tyler's
rebellion.
The Siege of Calais. So, the French had
put a siege on Calais and they were surrounded and a siege is where they
surround the city and if they ever come out they kill them and people can’t get
food to them so they eventually run out of food and have to give up otherwise
they’ll die of starvation. So they didn’t want to do that and they couldn’t
stop and it was a long time, so the leader wrote a letter to the king of I
don’t remember, the king of someplace to come and help them. And then he sent
the letter. So it was 3 months and then the king came but he didn’t do anything
so they all waited and waited but he didn’t do anything and then, a long time
later, he went away without doing anything. So they were angry and then they
said “we have to give up” so they did and they said “spare us” and they said
“the rest can go but pick 6 men and I will do anything I want with those men”
so they said “well, we have to.” So the bravest and wealthiest and best man of
the city said “I will go” and the best other 5 men said the same thing so the
king said “we will put you to death” but the queen said “NOO! Don’t” and then she
said “I will set them free with food and clothing” but the king said “I wish
you weren’t here but I will do it” so he gave them to her and she gave them
food and clothing and some money and sent them off.
Tell your favorite part of the Wind in the
Willows.
So Toady was going, going, going, going and
singing while he went. And then he saw a motor car and he was so happy. And it
went poop, poop, poop and then it came closer. But then he said “Oh, no” and
then he fainted – because it was the very people he had stolen the motorcar
from! So he fainted. And the people inside the motorcar said “Oh, no, there is
a poor washerwoman!” And then they took her up and then he started to feel
better so he sat up and said “oh, my, could I sit in the front seat” “Oh sure”
said the person next to toady. And then he said “Oh, can I drive the car? I’m
sure I have watched you good enough” and they said “okay” and then he started
slow but went fast, faster until he was zooming. And then he went “I am no
washer woman, I am the masterful toad!” and he drove it right into the pond.
And the he was singing a song a bit like this “The motorcar went poop poop, all
down the road, and who should drive it into the pond, Ingenious Mr. Toad!” but
before he was singing he was saying “oh, drat, oh, drat,” but that was before
he was driving the car. And then he said “oh, no a policeman and ran away from
the policeman.
Describe your favorite picture from this term's picture study.
So it’s in a temple sort of thing and they are
looking at a bunch of pictures, like we also did, and there are two people and
there is a big view of Rome and its open at the side and there are some statues
and art and its like a temple or something like that.
12.22.2020
Classics Challenge: Laddie
Classics Challenge - Adaption - 2 for 1 deal! Sanditon/Emma
And while for the purposes of this review, I'm pretty much sticking to the classic part, the ending which I believe was added in the 70s, was not horrific. Unlike the PBS series which started out promising with a few odd sections (like what is going on with those "siblings" and why does the heroine never wear her hair up!) and within a few episodes was cring worthy. Then the ending made a bad situation worse. Just don't. Don't. It was so bad I just couldn't even make it my Classics Challenge selection because I need to pretend that adaption doesn't exist.
So because that was so vile, I had to get the taste of bad Austen out of my mouth and started re-reading some of her other works. Some in written form, some in audio. While I often struggle with audiobooks for initial reads, I find them great for re-reading books I love and know well. Because I'm not totally lost if it gets loud for a second or I zone out and it prevents me from skimming and forces me to really take in the story at a slower pace. And with the quarentine, I went ahead and got Emma. so now I can at least have a good adaption to ponder for my real Classics Challenge selection.
Emma. My first Austen. My favorite Austen for many years . It might be surpassed by Persuasion now. But nostalgia comes back when I read or watch it so I'd actually have to say its a tie and whichever I'm currently reading is my favorite.
It really does hold up to repeated reads. It's so witty and funny. The characters are both amusing but also not dickensian. You can imaging actually meeting these people. A lot of time you might not want to, but you can! I was struck by how different Emma feels from other Austen's works in that it was so very home centered. Emma didn't travel to Bath or London. It's all about her home and community which seemed very relevant right now.
I've heard others say it isn't the best introduction to Austen but I think for teens, it's great. At least it was for me. I totally felt like Emma as a teen. I wanted to do something, to be somebody and at times, I thought it all figured out. As does Emma. But as a teen (or 30-something) when you figure out that maybe the world still wouldn't be perfect if everybody just acted the way you want them to and you don't have all the answers, it's nice to have the idea of Emma and the family and community that still love her, faults and all, to depend on.
Now onto the movie. It was surprisingly good. I'll admit I was skeptical.
I knew it would be beautiful. And it was.
I knew the costumes would be aamzing. And (with a few oddball pieces as exceptions - Why was Frank Churchill wearing stretchy pants?), they were.
It was just so enjoyable to see onscreen. And hear, the music was delightful. It features a bit more prominently than I was expecting but I did like it.
But my worries were that the previews had portrayed it almost farsical. And besides knowing Miranda Hart would make an excellent Ms. Bates, I wasn't so sure about some of the casting.
Johnny Flynn did not strike me as Mr. Knightley. But, it was kind of amusing but at the time I was watching it, I was also reading Mansfield Park and it struck me as similar - although I'm not sure that's a compliment to myself!
Her brother was not handsome: no, when they first saw him he was absolutely plain, black and plain; but still he was the gentleman, with a pleasing address. The second meeting proved him not so very plain: he was plain, to be sure, but then he had so much countenance, and his teeth were so good, and he was so well made, that one soon forgot he was plain; and after a third interview, after dining in company with him at the Parsonage, he was no longer allowed to be called so by anybody. He was, in fact, the most agreeable young man the sisters had ever known, and they were equally delighted with him.
So he did grow on me. It's a very different sort of telling of Mr. Knightley's part of the story than Gwenyth Paltrow version that I am also fond on, I really liked him in the role. He played the line between showing his emotions and frustrations and being a bit more privately bumbling and still being the dignified gentleman in public. He might have been my favorite actor to play him which is saying a lot because Mr. Knightley is my favorite male book character. Yes, he beats Mr. Darcy. Now, I still really like the Jeremy Northam's Mr. Knightley a lot too. Neither is quite the book Knightley but there is room in my movie life for both versions.
Ms. Bates and Mr. Woodhouse were as expected, wonderful although they didn't get a lot of screen time. In fact, I can't say I disliked any of the cast. Emma herself wasn't my favorite part of the movie but she did a good job and Anya Taylor-Joy does a good job with her faces.
But my one disappointment was that it really did rely on the facial acting and the scenery and costume to tell a lot of the story. They did the job well but I found it didn't have the verbal wit I love about Austen's works. I am pretty flexible with my views on adaptations in that I don't mind them changing lines or scenes as long as they stay true to the book's ideas and don't stray towards obnoxiously anachronstic. I like both the the movie and the books endings of North and South for example. I didn't mind the nosebleed nor have a problem with Mr. Knightley's tuches making an appearance and I don't really fault this version for not having the verbal wit because it just went a different direction, I just missed it. On of my favorite scenes is when Emma and Mr. Knightley have there little verbal spat over Harriet and I think it is so because its on of the few where the words are really flying in a way that reminds me of the book.
Emma/Sandition is (are?) my Adaption Classics for the Back to the Classic's challenge.
Classics Challenge: How the Heather Looks
(And for goodness sakes, don't read the afterward. Enjoy the slice of life of the family for what it is. And that's all I'll say about that!)
12.16.2020
The Man in the Brown Suit
Classics Challenge: The Adventures of Tom Sawyer
12.13.2020
A bit of an update
Waiting for Santa to drive down the village in his tractor :-)
Kid's only wanted Christmas tree for lighting. That means we had a nice slow breakfast - with really bad pictures!